3PAO vs C3PAO
They sound almost identical, they both assess against NIST frameworks, and some firms hold both designations. But a FedRAMP 3PAO and a CMMC C3PAO belong to different programs, answer to different accreditors, and assess different organizations — and one cannot substitute for the other.
Last updated: 2026-11-17.
| 3PAO (FedRAMP) | C3PAO (CMMC) | |
|---|---|---|
| Full name | Third-Party Assessment Organization | Certified Third-Party Assessment Organization |
| Program | FedRAMP (General Services Administration) — cloud services for federal agencies | CMMC, Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (Department of Defense) — defense industrial base contractors handling Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI) |
| Framework | NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5 baselines (Low ~125, Moderate ~325, High ~421 controls — approximate) | NIST SP 800-171 Rev 2 (110 requirements at Level 2) |
| Accreditor | A2LA, under ISO/IEC 17020 plus FedRAMP requirements | The Cyber AB (sole accreditation body); C3PAOs must attain full ISO/IEC 17020-based accreditation within 27 months of initial authorization (Cyber AB R2001) |
| Who is assessed | Cloud service providers (CSPs) | DoD primes and subcontractors (Organizations Seeking Certification) |
| Additional requirements on the assessor | — | D&B risk screen, FOCI (foreign ownership, control, or influence) analysis, and its own CMMC Level 2 certification before assessing others |
| Scale | 49 recognized assessors; 559 FedRAMP Certified products (Marketplace, verified live Nov 16, 2026) | Fewer than 100 C3PAOs serving 100,000+ defense industrial base companies, with booking cycles reportedly 6–9 months out |
Not interchangeable — but partially reusable
The two regimes share roughly 50% control overlap between NIST SP 800-53 and NIST SP 800-171, so evidence can be partially reused across programs. But each program requires its own assessment by its own assessor type. A FedRAMP authorization does not satisfy CMMC, and a CMMC certification does not satisfy FedRAMP.
Both regimes also bar the assessor from advising on the same scope it assesses — the independence rule is common to both.
Firms holding both designations
Some firms hold both a FedRAMP 3PAO recognition and a CMMC C3PAO authorization, including:
- Coalfire
- Schellman
- A-LIGN
- Aprio
- TalaTek
- Fortreum
- ControlCase
Holding both designations means the firm can perform either kind of assessment — as separate engagements, under separate programs, with separate assessor teams where the rules require it. It does not mean one assessment covers both programs.
CMMC timing
CMMC's phased rollout began November 10, 2025, with full implementation planned by November 10, 2028. The assessor shortage on the CMMC side is sharper than on the FedRAMP side: fewer than 100 C3PAOs for more than 100,000 defense industrial base companies, with booking cycles reportedly running 6–9 months out. If your organization needs both a FedRAMP authorization and a CMMC certification, plan the two assessments as parallel tracks with separate timelines — and book the C3PAO early.
Which one do you need?
- You sell a cloud service to federal agencies → you need FedRAMP, and a 3PAO. Start with what a 3PAO is and the process.
- You are a DoD contractor or subcontractor handling CUI → you need CMMC, and a C3PAO.
- Both → you need both assessments. The ~50% control overlap means some evidence transfers, but budget and schedule them separately.
Frequently asked questions
Is a C3PAO just a 3PAO for defense?
Close, but the programs differ in more than the customer: different frameworks (800-53 vs 800-171), different accreditors (A2LA vs The Cyber AB), and different requirements on the assessor itself — a C3PAO must hold its own CMMC Level 2 certification and pass D&B and FOCI screening before assessing others.
If my company is FedRAMP authorized, does that help with CMMC?
Yes, partially: roughly half the controls overlap, so evidence and implemented controls can be reused. But CMMC still requires its own assessment by a C3PAO — FedRAMP authorization does not satisfy CMMC requirements.
Can one firm do both assessments for me?
A firm holding both designations (such as Coalfire, Schellman, A-LIGN, Aprio, TalaTek, or Fortreum) can perform both assessments — as separate engagements under separate programs. The assessments themselves are not combined.